Zha vs zigbee2mqtt. ZHA is not slower than Zigbee2MQTT.

Zha vs zigbee2mqtt I picked up the Sonoff Zigbee 3. 4 Supervisor 2023. From what I understand See full list on thesmarthomejourney. Is there a problem that you are solving by moving to the Sonoff? The Conbee II is still on the list of recommended coordinators for ZHA. The pros for Z2M are that it's going to support a wider range of devices, and give you better control of them. I’m thinking of moving it all to Conbee. Zuerst Phoscon, dann Zigbee2MQTT (Z2M) und zuletzt Zigbee Home Automation (ZHA): Ich habe alle drei ZigBee-Gateway-Softwarelösungen mit Home-Assistant ausgiebig getestet und verwende jetzt ZHA, was auch das primäre Thema dieses Artikels ist. For home automation, I'll take stability over speed. Instead I Dec 24, 2023 · Hi everyone, I recently moved (well, still moving!) from Samsung SmartThings (ST) to Home Assistant using the HA Green as my platform with a SkyConnect dongle. If you’re new to all this, my advice would be to try ZHA first, and then re-pair your devices with Zigbee2MQTT if it doesn’t work out. It works flawlessly. All three options support majority of devices. Any help In dem ewigen Vergleich zwischen ZHA und Zigbee2MQTT, welcher ist wirklich der König? Die Antwort ist nicht so einfach, wie du vielleicht denkst! In diesem V Aug 30, 2022 · ZHA vs Z2M. Jun 5, 2024 · The Sonoff ZBDongle-P is a great pick for those that want a hassle-free Zigbee setup and experience. Aug 23, 2023 · Z2M should be much more reliable than ZHA when you consider that anytime HA restarts (for updates, config changes, etc…), your zigbee network is completely restarted and reinitializes. Also, Zigbee2mqtt apparently added support for new devices quickly while ZHA request for a new device Multiple vendor hubs vs zigbee2mqtt (or ZHA) Recently got into HA, moving from a primarily homekit setup. If you decide half way through you want to go back to zha, you’ll still have to reconfigure all your devices. ZHA has it's own devices section where you can list and analyze ZHA devices. Sep 6, 2021 · I’ve been starting with ZHA and I have realised that Zigbee2mqtt seems to have better device support for the current devices I’ve been buying like Aqara TVOC sensor and Aqara power plug. Those who use HomeAssistant can use ZHA as a third variant for their Zigbee devices. Understanding Zigbee2MQTT (Z2M) Zigbee2MQTT is an open-source project that enables Zigbee dev Nov 1, 2023 · Yet another migration-thread… i know. I started with zha, moved to z2m for ~3 months, switched back to zha a week ago. What I’m worried about is the “HUB Software”. This is a common problem and Zigbee2mqtt suggests to disable ZHA (Zigbee2MQTT fails to start | Zigbee2MQTT) The strange thing, I don’t have this integration running. Learn about their device support, ease of use, integration, stability, and adapters. See pros and cons, tips and links to videos for both options. Hue, Elko, EcoDim Dec 8, 2020 · I was struggling with trying to get the deCONZ Add-on working with the ZHA integration on my Rpi4 with HassOS, only to find out that they can’t both be on the same device (they could, but it brought my existing ZHA network to its knees). What is best is what works fro you. I have migrated most of my automations and scenes (as scripts) and really enjoying the added features and control I can have now. In diesem Video nehme ich dich mit auf meine Reise von ZHA zu Zigbee2MQTT und zeige dir, warum ich mich für diesen Wechsel entschieden habe. Has anyone moved their zigbee devices from ZHA to Z2M? I am curious if I will see more device entities with zigbee2MQTT. I've tried z2m, Deconz, and ZHA. It’s officially supported in both ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT since the very beginning, with firmware and flashing instructions released by the manufacturer. So long as you define the group in ZHA (and aren't using a home assistant group) they should be functionally identical. I'd like something that is really plug-and-play, so I was hoping to find a gateway-type device perhaps network-connected. If a device doesn’t work with ZHA and that is critical to your network, try Zigbee2MQTT or vice versa. Snappy and reliable are the goals. I still have it running my old automations while I transition, but I moved Home Assistant back onto my server as a docker container, using docker compose (well technically Portainer) to set up Home Assistant, Mosquitto, Zigbee2MQTT, and MariaDB. ZHA es más fácil de configurar y usar, pero tiene un poco de compatibilidad con dispositivos limitados, especialmente para dispositivos oscuros y raros. My take on it is here: ZHA Vs Zigbee2Mqtt - #3 by jerrm. For example, I have zigbee buttons and rotary knobs around the house used to trigger various actions. Both integrations are very capable and well documented, support a variety of devices and are supported in Home Assistant. ZHA (Zigbee Home Automation) is one way of using Zigbee inside HA, Z2M is another. My hardware: I’ve got a flashed Sonoff P-dongle and about 20 devices (temp-sensors, light switches, motion-sensors, some battery driven, some on the grid) and 2 Zigbee repeaters. I recently switched from zigbee2mqtt to ZHA because the support for Alarm Keypads was easier and better on ZHA than on zigbee2mqtt and it's been running rock solid for like ~6 months. Converting to Zigbee2MQTT Converting between ZHA (built-in Zigbee Home Assistant) and Zigbee2MQTT is a lot more involved, and neither solution is going to 100% solve every issue. Was advised that ZHA doesn You will then need to remove zha and go through and rename your entities from mqtt to match exactly what you had in zha otherwise you will need to redo all your automations etc. This guide was originally written and tested these versions but should also work with later versions: Home Assistant 2023. After my first attempts with ZHA I recognized some issues like not showing battery status on some of my Aqara E1 Thermostats so that I decided to test Zigbee2MQTT. But it’s unstable at scale. I’ve seen mixed reviews on the Sonoff WiFi bridges, but have no first hand If you bought a Zigbee coordinator stick, you can choose between different integrations or add-ons to control your Zigbee devices in Home Assistant. Really configurable, compatible with a shit ton of devices, awesome Dev/great support, and absolutely rock solid. . You will not get a speed boost with switching and without further troubleshooting your setup your issues may remain. It’s a bigger antenna and Z2M handles all my bulbs. Perhaps ZigBee2MQTT? Or any other suggestions. It just seems more reliable overall. Apr 10, 2022 · This video is A MUST SEE comparison between the three main integrations: ZHA, Zigbee2MQTT, and deCONZ. Fortunately, every under switch What to use? What's better? What's easier to install? All and more of those questions will be answered in this video. As far as performance goes, I don't see any difference. Especially painful is the good support for Wyze Lock and there are issues on GitHub which require reverse engineering raw bits. Then I use Z2M with a networked controller from Kiev (!!). And a zigbee2mqtt network with an CC2531 stick. After using ZHA and zigbee2mqtt I prefer zigbee2mqtt dashboard over ZHA configuration. For communication ZHA uses an open source Python library zigpy, which implements a hardware independent Zigbee stack . I’m looking at buying a refurb dell mini pc 16g ram and 250gb ssd to start and want to start with zigbee but I’m not sure if it’s zigbee or zigbee2mqtt I’m best using. Jan 30, 2021 · I tried ZHA first, deCONZ seconds and Zigbee2MQTT last. To be fair, I never checked it with ZHA, but reading reviews online suggested that it would only work with Zigbee2MQTT and not ZHA. This is key because that zha_event trigger let’s me super load my switches. Also, you can’t update HA without also updating ZHA, and possibly introducing instability due to the new release. The problem is that I’m There are a few featured that could be considered an advantage of Z2M over ZHA. I have about 60 unique zigbee devices and am running dual coordinators at the moment with about 35 still still running on ZHA and about 25 running on my new Zigbee2MQTT network. Zigbee networks take a while to come back completely after such resets. And yes, it’s require manual re-pairing. Configuration. I switched because I couldn't get aqara tvoc sensors working with zha, ended up working better with z2m but still cut out after a week or so. 0 - latest Background Until recently Philips Hue devices have been controlled locally via a local Durch die Notwendigkeit eines zusätzlichen MQTT-Brokers, ist das Setup anfangs aufwendiger, siehe Home-Assistant Docker Conbee 2 und Zigbee2MQTT / deCONZ; ZHA. Nov 28, 2024 · You are way past the point of overthinking this. Automations will be in Home Assistant. In addition, I'm running a separate Z2M for an individual room with ~20 devices (IKEA, Hue, Xaomi, OSRAM) which are working 100% reliable since years with a zzh CC2652R coordinator. ZHA surfaces the “zha_event” for when I hit any switches even when state doesn’t change (ie on when already on). I have a 70+ device network established with ZHA but its limitations are making me want to switch (again) to Zigbee2MQTT (Z2M for brevity). Looks like ZHA seems to be "most used?" with zigbee2mqtt coming in second? Or am I missing something? Shooting for WAF, and Therefore the key to a great and healthy Zigbee network mesh is to add/have many “Zigbee Router” devices relatively close to each other (and always powered on) in order for the Zigbee network as a whole to get good coverage and range, as well as improving the overall robustness and robustness and resilience in the network to handle the loss of some Zigbee Routers in case of failures. 10. Z2M will give you a few more diagnostics, but that will depend on if your smart home is a setup and leave alone, or if you are a tinkerer who constantly fiddles with it and has to look at diagnostic graphs all the time. I just got a HA Green. Dec 10, 2023 · J'ai comparé les intégrations Zigbee Home Automation (ZHA) et Zigbee2MQTT (Z2M). 🙂 May 6, 2024 · Hi all I’m a complete noob, in fact I’ve not even started anything yet. Fazit Aug 15, 2024 · My Experience with Z2M vs ZHA on Home Assistant Supervisor. Zigbee2mqtt setup allows you to use your Zigbee devices without a vendor's gateway. Basically, use the one that supports the devices you have. Do the radio migration in ZHA or go fresh with the ZMQTT route? I’m reading that ZMQTT scales better over 50 devices, but could be incompatible with some devices. But no the lights get the firmware when I get to them IF I’m solving a particular problem. Jan 11, 2023 · Users share their experiences and opinions on the reliability and configuration of ZHA and Zigbee2Mqtt, two methods to integrate Zigbee devices with Home Assistant. Both have some OTA support, z2m is probably better, but the latest zha toolkit can now use the z2m OTA repository, leveling the playing field, even if not fully GUI integrated. I like the overall concept way better. I have used all three and ZHA is a built-in integration, and quite intuitive to use. ZHA vs. Zigbee2MQTT Anyone having issues or opinions about which Zigbee home assistant integration to use with the blue series switches? I’ve seen mixed things on the forums, some seem to have better UI experiences with ZHA whereas some people seemed to have issues getting things set up with Z2M. Dec 13, 2022 · ZHA vs Zigbee2MQTT: Which one is for you? This question has been asked many times in the Home Assistant community and unfortunately there is no definitive answer that would fit most users. If I were still working in system management caring for 65000 workstations that need updates sure. Sin embargo, he aquí por qué es posible que desee hacer esto: Dispositivos no compatibles: Digamos que usa ZHA como su controlador diario, pero ZHA aún no admite ese conmutador, pero sí en Zigbee2MQTT. Mar 10, 2020 · Everyone has their preferences. I have about a dozen zigbee devices connected to HA via ZHA+Conbee II. TLDR This video offers a comprehensive comparison of three popular methods for integrating Zigbee devices with Home Assistant: ZHA, Zigbee2MQTT, and deCONZ. Any tips on the process, or does it simply mean I will be reworking all my automations? May 9, 2022 · I’m using ZHA for my Zigbee netwoork but notice that using Zigbee2MQTT may provide additional functionality for some of my devices as well as open up the possibility to use devices not available through ZHA (yet). Entre las opciones disponibles, Zigbee emerge como un pilar fundamental en este ámbito, facilitando la conexión y el manejo de dispositivos inteligentes. Choose Zigbee2MQTT if: You want support for advanced devices or firmware updates. This vid Zigbee2MQTT should be officially recommended, because ZHA puts Zigbee devices in a very bad light So, I own the following devices that I'm evaluating: Aeotec aërQ (ZWA039-C), Aqara TVOC (AAQS-S01) and Sonoff ZigBee LCD Temperature & Humidity Sensor (SNZB-02D). I see this runs ZHA out of the box but I am now reading I might want to use zigbee2mqtt instead? Can anyone advise? Can the ZBT-1 run zigbee2mqtt reliably or do I want a Sonoff dongle? I also just read there is a ZHA gives pretty well the same functionality for the devices themselves. My experience has been great much more stable and I am able to trigger an automation from an aqara FP1 much faster than before. Also it’s a one way ticket. 2 Operating System 10. Oct 17, 2024 · I’m new to everything. My goal: Migrate my Zigbee-Devices/Network from ZHA (Zigbee Home Assistant) integration to Z2M (Zigbee2MQTT). Zha works great with the conbee II stick. The last couple of days I’ve thoroughly tested these integrations and I will show you the pros and cons of each integration/add-on. There's been a ton of work into ZHA and with Zigbee 3. Since i have an original Conbee, its not compatible with zigbee2mqtt, but if that fails, i’ll give zha a go. The key feature for me, is that ZigBee2MQTT is KING when it comes to supporting weird and cheap devices and hardware. It worked! BUT, I couldn’t get my Xiaomi PIR sensor to pair with ZHA. People that have went to ZMQTT Jun 15, 2023 · I got a spare USB dongle, so I got both ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT running in parallel, and I switched every device one by one. All coordinators compatible with zigpy can be used with ZHA. Zigbee2MQTT also maintains its own list of supported devices, which currently number nearly 4000. 0 I don't think there's much difference in device compatibility. That being said generally I've had significantly more success with ZigBee2mqtt. 3 is out. It was a toss up between Zigbee2MQTT and Deconz but tried Deconz first and it is working ok. Jun 23, 2024 · Today, we’re diving deep into two popular Zigbee integration options for Home Assistant: Zigbee2MQTT (Z2M) and Zigbee Home Automation (ZHA). Zigbee2mqtt was by far the best experience. Schnall dich an, denn wir tauchen tief ZigBee2MQTT vs ZHA Support I was using ZigBee2MQTT for months and then switched to ZHA and it worked good for a couple months but now it’s unreliable I don’t know for sure if it’s from ZHA but which one do you guys prefer and why? Apr 10, 2022 · The process to compare Zigbee2MQTT vs ZHA vs deCONZ. Getting Zigbee2MQTT set up Nov 22, 2023 · Hi so I’m preparing a blueprint for my smart home and I need some help understanding & deciding which hub & interface I should use. 5 Frontend 20230911. But you cant really go wrong with either. I don’t want to convert my existing Zigbee network from ZHA to Zigbee2MQTT as the thought of re-pairing all my devices and adjusting automations fills me with dread. So now I’m wondering if the Zigbee2mqtt Add-on will work alongside ZHA on the same Pi. Hi everyone, I’d like to share my experience in choosing between Zigbee2MQTT (Z2M) and Zigbee Home Automation (ZHA) on Home Assistant (HA). Nov 2, 2024 · Once set up, Zigbee2MQTT seems to work well, and I’ve seen others state that they’ve found it more stable than ZHA. Nov 23, 2024 · Converting similar tools I recently converted from the native Z-Wave JS to Z-Wave JS UI. Dabei stelle ich ZHA vs Zigbee2MQTT vs deCONZ Conbee II ready to go on latest firmware. What are the pros and cons for using ZHA or Z2M and ZHA groups are ZigBee groups this is a network feature where one command is sent to the entire group. Mar 28, 2024 · The two most popular integrations are considered in this article: Zigbee2MQTT and ZHA (Zigbee Home Automation). Afterwards I did notice that some of my devices have extra sensor attributes exposed through Zigbee2MQTT than Deconz so if I had my time over again I’d probably try Zigbee2MQTT. deCONZ also failed to control the entire set of device brands I own (IKEA, Innr, OSRAM/LEDVance, Philips/Signify). Zigbee2MQTT does offer some advantages and features over ZHA. The process was as follows: For every integration or add-on, I had to start with a fresh Home Assistant installation and then I installed the integration or add-on so ZHA or Zigbee2MQTT or deCONZ. We will look at Pros and Cons of both ZH Feb 28, 2021 · Hi, I got a general question. I am using Conbee II stick, and HomeAssistant is running on top of Proxmox/Docker. I have the sky Connect USB stick and wondered which of the two protocols I would be best using I am presuming I can choose between either and in one of my set ups I have used ZHA which seems to work fine, but then in someone’s post I saw that using zigbee2mqtt there looked to be more control over the devices enabling changing settings on some sensors? Oct 27, 2021 · What's better for connecting Zigbee devices directly to Home Assistant - Zigbee2MQTT or ZHA (Zigbee Home Automation)? ️ Found this video useful and want to s Oct 11, 2024 · It seems to me ZHA is loosing the “battle” to zigbee2mqtt, device support is lacking and its not trivial to add new devices with quirks in ZHA. But i’ve read a lot and can’t find a good solution. So now I have 2 zigbee networks 1 zigbee2mqtt and 1 Phillips hue. I have ever once cared how. A new device on the market is added very fast, and later ported into ZHA or Deconz from I'm using many Aqara devices and some IKEA bulbs. As for ZHA vs Z2M. I recently moved from ZHA to zigbee2mqtt. I’ve been doing a lot of reading up on ZHA/ZMQTT and I’m a little torn about what I should do. Just curios cause I found an article that says: "After switching to ZHA, I can definitely confirm that the SkyConnect with Z2M does not run half as well, as fast or as far as it does with ZHA! The improvement in LQI mentioned in the video is apparently simply a display or calculation problem!" ZHA is more responsive than Zigbee2MQTT, but Zigbee2MQTT seems to be less flakey once you get the hang of it (which, admittedly, is a bit of an oxymoron). The problem is that the zigbee stick is also addressed to by HA, which conflicts with Zigbee2MQTT and crashes it. Why cant Home Assistant do the same integration with zigbee2mqtt as they did with zwavejs2mqtt ditching the need for mqtt? Dec 17, 2024 · The choice between ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT depends on your needs: Choose ZHA if: You prefer a simple, plug-and-play experience. You don’t redesign your zigbee network I'm looking for some recommendations for Zigbee integration with HA. The ZHA vs Z2M debate has been going on in community forums and subreddits for as long as I can remember and it always seems to arrive to the same conclusion: Jan 5, 2025 · Do not forget that the first post in a community guide is a wiki - feel free to add to it or edit/correct it. Im going to start with simple automations, but I will want the most advanced features in the future as my knowledge of it grows. Dec 26, 2023 · In dem ewigen Vergleich zwischen ZHA und Zigbee2MQTT, welcher ist wirklich der König? Die Antwort ist nicht so einfach, wie du vielleicht denkst! In diesem Video stelle ich beide Systeme gegenüber und beleuchte ihre Stärken und Schwächen. How i Bit of advice please. Jun 21, 2022 · A discussion thread about the pros and cons of two zigbee integration options for Home Assistant: ZHA (native HA zigbee control) and Zigbee2Mqtt (separate zigbee system). two Sonoff USB dongles) b) are there any downsides (outside of the fact I have tons of Xiaomi Aqara sensors (motion, temperature, and door/window) paired directly to my HUSBZB-1 without the Xiaomi hub. But I think that HA might automatically try to discover the Dec 30, 2020 · I was ready to throw in the towel and try zha, it seems that maybe 6-10 months ago zha was having its day and rapidly rising, but there is an even bigger wealth of ecosystem with zigbee2mqtt. Ich gebe dir meine Empfehlung, basierend auf meinem Wissen und meiner 1,2-Jährigen Erfahrung mit beiden Systemen. You can choose deconz, zigbee2mqtt, or ZHA when using the conbee stick. If I just get the Xiaomi hub, is there an easy way to disable it’s cloud or is there some custom firmware for it? So the Conbee stick works with both ZHA and deCONZ, HUSBZB-1 is for ZHA but includes Z-Wave, and for zigbee2mqtt I Is anyone else ZHA faster than Zigbee2Mqtt? I recently upgraded from a HUSB-1 to a Sonoff Zigbee radio and even though the devices are located on the same place (making sure WiFi channels and such as not overlapping) and noticed that my lights are not as fast, mainly when using my motion sensors. ” There Search this forum or Google for ZHA vs Zigbee2MQTT and you'll learn the differences (there are literally so many treads on this). ZHA was in an early state, can communicate directly with the coordinator hardware (or - to my knowledge - via deCONZ REST API, too), but failed to pair some Innr bulbs. Switching from Zigbee2MQTT to ZHA: Step by Database of Zigbee devices compatible with ZHA, Tasmota, Zigbee2MQTT, deCONZ, ZiGate and ioBroker ZHA vs Zigbee2MQTT I've just been bitten by the HA bug over the last few weeks. Wer HomeAssistant einsetzt kann als dritte Variante ZHA für seine Zigbee-Geräte verwenden. Der Wechsel von einer Gateway-Lösung zur anderen kann abhängig von der Anzahl an verbundenen Jan 4, 2025 · ZHA (Zigbee Home Automation) is a Home Assistant integration for direct connection of Zigbee devices in Home Assistant. I’m familiar that Zigbee2MQTT has more device compatibility and features for automating, but ZHA seems to be more user friendly I am halfway through migrating from ZHA to Zigbee2MQTT. The main motivation would be to get rid of the Hue Bridges and to improve stability. Zha does have a very nice UI for managing, adding, removing devices. Hell it's built right into home assistant whereas the other options require add-ons like deconz or mqtt. g. Specifically, I'm trying to prep my system for the inovelli Blue switches, which will have supported integrations for both ZHA and zigbee2mqtt. Feb 10, 2023 · Hello everyone, I’m new to HA and just set up my first system on a nuc. Zigbee ZHA vs Zigbee2mqtt En el universo de las casas inteligentes, la elección del protocolo de comunicación es clave para la interconexión de dispositivos y el control eficiente del hogar. The home assistant zigb I would like to migrate away from the Hue Bridges. The creator shares their experience with installation, device support, ease of use, and automation capabilities for each option. The same applies to replacing your Conbee II. You are a beginner with Home Assistant and don’t need advanced features. And ZHA zigbee I got a sky connect and rather than migrate from the conbee / ZHA I decided to install zigbee2mqtt and move the devices one at a time, starting with the ones with automations. See also: ZHA commissioning and change of Zigbee2MQTT I have been running Zigbee2mqtt in Home Assistant for a long time. Feb 29, 2024 · ZHA was great at first and still works well for most stuff, but I find Zigbee2MQTT has much better device support and has a well designed user interface too. Mar 27, 2023 · I’m integrating zigbee using zigbee2mqtt. Je vous présente les avantages et inconvénients de chacune des intégrations. It also has slightly better device support in my experience. 09. Both run on Z-Wave JS, so the conversion is just copying a few files and copy-pasting your keys. Choose Zigbee2MQTT if: You want support for Nov 2, 2024 · One of the devices that I’ve recently bought seemingly fell into this latter category. com Nov 2, 2020 · Compare two open-source Zigbee gateways for Home Assistant: Zigbee2MQTT and ZHA. I’ve been running HA Supervisor on a Raspberry Pi 3B+ for a few years now. They highlight the advantages and disadvantages of both systems and give some recommendations based on their use-case. deConz seems to have issues with groups, ZHA is not really mature. Actually it's the same with zigbee2mqtt because MQTT plugin has autodiscovery functionality and zigbee2mqtt uses it to automatically add/remove/update devices from HA. Feb 1, 2020 · I have home assistant on a RPi4. There are many factors to consider here, interference, USB extension cable (a must!), enough routers, coordinator firmware etc. 8. Also some ZigBee stuff, mainly IKA lamps and switches. As far as I have seen, deconz doesn't support either of those. Dec 21, 2020 · My Zigbee devices are a bit of a mess. Siehe auch: ZHA Inbetriebnahme und Wechsel von Zigbee2MQTT. Sep 10, 2019 · Advantages? Comparisons of supported devices, capacity, range? Mainly planning to use Xiaomi Aqara devices for now, heard they did not always play nicely with ZHA. Oct 11, 2022 · NOTE: I searched through past topics and couldn’t get to a straight answer so starting a new thread especially now that HA Core 2022. ZHA (what I use) doesn't have UI to edit device bindings but it can show the network map (but it seems buggy at times). But it’s a lot more difficult to set up, and ZHA will probably work for most users. Let’s explore what Z2M is, and why it might be the better choice for your smart home. Sonoff WiFi Bridges. (See TL;DR below to skip my self-pitying life story!) My first ever post was asking how I can get the “decoupled” setting exposed and working for Zigbee switches (Aqara Smart Wall Switch H1 for example). Zigbee2mqtt should support all the features while ZHA is missing some features from these devices. Aug 20, 2021 · I’m curious if anyone jumped from deconz with the Conbee II over to zigbee2mqtt with the Conbee II. But investigate to see if those advantages/advantages will benefit you. ZHA is not slower than Zigbee2MQTT. Aug 9, 2022 · This has been asked before, but a long time ago, however I want to revisit it with a new angle… I understand that Z2M and ZHA can be run on the same machine, so long as you have 2 coordinators and those coordinators only do one or the other My extension of the question is, a) can the coordinators be the same device (e. I'm using a custom ZHA integration (zha-new) to do it, but I've been told that recent versions of the built in ZHA work just as good and don't require the hub either. But my recent move, and perhaps a future platform move, gave me reason to go with ZHA this Sep 23, 2022 · Zigbee2mqtt Home Assistant VS ZHA Home Assistant. 0 USB dongle and a few Zigbee devices to start playing around with. ZHA is (even) easier to set up, Z2M has more knobs and dials, a dedicated GUI that makes it a little easier to manage, and I like being able to monitor everything via MQTT for debugging and troubleshooting. Current Gateways: Hue, Conbee II, IKEA Units: about 40. many lamps firmware updates I ‘can do in a night’ they get done when they get done. Dec 17, 2024 · The choice between ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT depends on your needs: Choose ZHA if: You prefer a simple, plug-and-play experience. All three have good development and get new devices added. francisp (Francis) October 23, 2020, 2:34pm 103. Now I saw that in zigbee2mqtt the IKEA switches are showing a real switches and not only as battery like in ZHA where you need to check for events to automate. Oct 23, 2020 · deCONZ vs ZHA vs zigbee2mqtt. I like having both, so I know any Zigbee device I purchase going forward is likely to work in either ZHA or Zigbee2MQTT. Do you think one of these systems will eventually win out over the other? Hi, I am finally biting the bullet and moving from ZHA integration to Mosquitto/Zigbee2MQTT. So of those two, that's what I'd recommend. So which am I best going with zigbee ZHA vs zigbee2mqtt. Jan 12, 2020 · Today I tried out ZHA (been using deCONZ) to see if I could get my ecosmart remotes to pair (I haven’t been able to pair them with Home Assistant using a Conbee II and deCONZ). A user shares their experience and comparison of using ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT for Home Assistant smart home system. Nov 27, 2023 · I’ve been running the Conbee2 for years now on ZHA and I’m about to replace it with a Sonoff. All three work well when setup. Using a CC1352P-2 as coordinator and ZHA right now. Both ZHA and z2m are open source. I own Zigbee light bulbs and remotes (mainly from IKEA). Zigbee2mqtt. I’ve got the official Mosquito MQTT broker installed and working Zigbee ZHA vs Zigbee2mqtt ¿Cuál es mejor para tu hogar inteligente? Como puede ver en esta lista simple, ambas integraciones de Zigbee tienen sus pros y sus contras. Now here it gets interesting: I was originally on Z2M, my server crashed (including the backups) so I had to For example, zigbee2mqtt supports editing device bindings and viewing device map through the UI. I’m looking to go for something I don’t have to replace for a some time. they are both great. These devices go to sleep. To be honest, I think most people tend to decide between ZHA and Zigbee2mqtt (which you will see abbreviated as Z2M). Zigbee. Connected to my Zigbee2mqtt network are mainly xiaomi devices (motion sensors, contact sensors) and Ikea devices (power outlets) I also have a phillips hue with 10 Phillips hue lights and 4 Innr lights. Users share their experiences, opinions and tips on device support, setup, configuration and compatibility. henry8866: tw: is there a dedicated place for zigbee2mqtt Zigbee2MQTT alone can map certain buttons of a switch; Due to the need of an additional MQTT broker, the setup is more complex at the beginning, see Home-Assistant Docker Conbee 2 and Zigbee2MQTT / deCONZ; ZHA. They have different functions and the preference will be different per user. I believe I will want a Zigbee dongle for the Green? I bought a ZBT-1. ZHA en Home Assistant hace el trabajo para la mayoría de las personas, mientras que Zigbee2MQTT es el rey de los dispositivos compatibles. Most of them are subjective, others are valid and important. deconz is great and really stable for me, don’t get me wrong, but zigbee2mqtt seems to have a much wider array of devices, especially for US users, whereas “most things” work with deconz with the attitude of “give it a try, it should, but if not request a new device be added. You may also want to look into the husbzb-1 stick. However, it seems z2m supports WAY less devices than ZHA. Your Zigbee devices are mainstream and well-supported. I literally watched hours on youtube on how to set up Zigbee2MQTT but there are just a minor numbers of dealing with SkyConnect. xkux aeewg jdfqy fkjyg olnu cnsnmo llepvnkx aoak wmype czpyw